About Us

20+ Years Experience

Island Rarities was founded to become one of the leading companies in the state of New York for sourcing rare antique collectibles. Whether you’re a collector looking for an 1800’s piece of history to complete a set or just someone looking to hunt down a specific item that has sentimental value, we are the ones that will get the job done.

Why Choose Us?

Whether you’re a collector looking for an 1800’s piece of history to complete a set or just someone looking to hunt down a specific item that has sentimental value, we are the ones that will get the job done.

Free Shipping

Orders Over $500

quick payments

100% Secure

Great Pricing

Huge Selection of Coins

Top Support

100% Client Satisfaction

"My company has been cleaning this facility for a few years now and subsequently I’ve bought many coins throughout the years. This group is VERY professional, especially for the stigma of phone sale companies. I’ve showed up early before a cleaning to gain information about certain coins I have in my collection and they sat me down with analysts and walked me through pricing trends. I’m very impressed!"

CleanAmerica Inc.

Customer

"By far the best service I have had buying coins, they always select the Best quality coins. Bob the Vault Manager really knows what he is doing."

Sean Rosen

Customer

"Knowledgable, helpful, reliable, & respectful. I will continue to buy with them."

Elise P

Customer

"Wonderful Company highly recommended , Bob the vault manager has great knowledge about coins."

M Rock

Customer

Items may be returned for credit or refund if postmarked within 30 days of receipt, and only if not damaged or removed from original encapsulation. Please package all returns securely, including a copy of your invoice or other documentation identifying the shipment as a return, and insure the shipment; upon receipt, Island will issue a refund within 2 business days.

Client Inquiries

Trying to answer some of your questions that may be going through your mind. Have a look at some of our FAQs.

Professional Team

Phasellus ullamcorper odio vitae eleifend ultricies. Duis dictum vestibulum ante vitae ullamcorper. Phasellus ullamcorper odio vitae eleifend ultricies lectus orci congue magna in egestas nulla libero nisla.

Jewelry Manager

Victoria Hansen

Jewelry Master

Tamara Barton

Jewelry Repair

Grace Herrera

Jewelry Designer

Lucy Morrison

Discover The Collection

Whether you’re a collector looking for an 1800’s piece of history to complete a set or just someone looking to hunt down a specific item that has sentimental value, we are the ones that will get the job done. 

Free Delivery on $500+ Orders

Call Now Button